The Box No One Opened
Spoiler warning: this page reveals the full solution, including the killer.
Full clue-by-clue reasoning for this case, where row and column constraints quickly narrow down the board and leave only one cell for the victim.
The cast
EleanorSuspect
GraceSuspect
JamesSuspect
IvySuspect
PeterThe victim — alone with the killer
KatherineThe killer
The map
Cells are written (row, column), counted from the top-left corner. Five rooms, 36 cells:
| Room | Cells (row, column) | Objects |
|---|---|---|
| Terrace | Rows 1–5, columns 1–1 (5 cells) | Tree (2,1) |
| Pool | (1,2), (2,2), (3,2), (4,2), row 5 columns 2–3 (6 cells) | — |
| Garage | Row 1 columns 3–6, row 2 columns 5–6, (3,6), (4,6), (5,6) (9 cells) | Table (1,6), chair (1,4) |
| Reception | Row 2 columns 3–4, row 3 columns 3–5, row 4 columns 3–5 (8 cells) | Carpet (4,4), armchair (4,5) |
| Pavilion | Row 5 columns 4–5, row 6 columns 1–6 (8 cells) | Rock (6,1), crate (6,3) |
The table, tree, rock and crate cells stayed empty for the whole game — nobody was placed on them and they never got a cross. That is our observation from the board; the tutorial lists objects such as crates as scenery that cannot be occupied.
Clue-by-clue reasoning
Eleanor — “She was on a carpet.”
Only one carpet exists on the board, in the Reception room at (4,4).
→ Eleanor = (4,4), the carpet cell. Row 4 and column 4 are now taken.
Grace — “She was in the Garage. She was in the top row. She was in a corner of the room.”
The Garage’s top row is row 1, and the only occupiable corner cell in the Garage is (1,3).
→ Grace = (1,3). Row 1 and column 3 are now taken.
James — “He was beside a tree.”
The tree is at (2,1), so the cells beside it are (1,1), (2,2), and (3,1).
→ Row 1 is taken by Grace, removing (1,1). Katherine must be two rows south of James, and since Katherine can only be in row 5, James must be in row 3, removing (2,2). → James = (3,1). Row 3 and column 1 are now taken.
Ivy — “She was not in a corner of the room. There was exactly a chair in her room.”
The chair is at (1,4) in the Garage, so Ivy must be in the Garage. The non-corner cells in the Garage are (1,4), (1,5), (2,6), (3,6), and (4,6).
→ Row 4 is taken by Eleanor, removing (4,6). Column 4 is taken by Eleanor, removing (1,4). Row 1 is taken by Grace, removing (1,5). Row 3 is taken by James, removing (3,6). → Ivy = (2,6). Row 2 and column 6 are now taken.
Katherine — “She was east of Grace. She was two rows south of James.”
Grace is at (1,3), so Katherine must be in a column greater than 3. James is at (3,1), so Katherine must be in row 5.
→ Row 4 and column 4 are taken by Eleanor, row 1 by Grace, and column 3 by Grace. Being east of Grace means column > 3, and being two rows south of James means row 5. Column 6 is taken by Ivy, leaving only (5,5). → Katherine = (5,5). Row 5 and column 5 are now taken.
Peter — “The victim. He was alone with the killer.”
The victim’s clue gives no specific cell, but Peter must be placed in the only remaining open cell.
→ Rows 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and columns 1, 3, 4, 5, 6 are taken by the other suspects, leaving only (6,2). → Peter = (6,2). Since Peter is the victim and was alone with the killer, the killer is the other suspect in the Pavilion, which is Katherine.
The solved board
One person per row, one per column — the full placement. Thick lines are room borders.
| ✕ | ✕ | G | chair | ✕ | table |
| tree | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕Garage | I |
| J | ✕Pool | ✕ | ✕Reception | ✕ | ✕ |
| ✕Terrace | ✕ | ✕ | E | armchair | ✕ |
| ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | K | ✕ |
| rock | P | crate | ✕Pavilion | ✕ | ✕ |
K Katherine (killer), P Peter (victim), E Eleanor, G Grace, J James, I Ivy. Row 1 is the top row; column 1 is on the left.
🔍 The killer was Katherine
She shared the Pavilion with Peter — the one condition the game always uses to name the culprit.
Want more worked examples?
Row and column uniqueness gets you most of the way, but checking the exact wording of a clue finishes the job — this case shows both, and it comes up constantly on harder boards.
More walkthroughs & deeper strategy
- Object Glossary – every tile explained
- Strategy Guide – advanced deduction patterns
- How to Play – the six core rules
