The Door That Should Not Open
Spoiler warning: this page reveals the full solution, including the killer.
Full clue-by-clue reasoning for this Easy case, with a room map and the one spot where two layouts look right: Katherine and Eleanor.
The cast
JamesSuspect
DanielSuspect
KatherineSuspect
EleanorSuspect
MarcoThe victim — alone with the killer
CharlotteThe killer
The map
Cells are written (row, column), counted from the top-left corner. Five rooms, 36 cells:
| Room | Cells (row, column) | Objects |
|---|---|---|
| Rooftop | Rows 1–3, columns 1–2 (6 cells) | Chair (3,2) |
| Pool | Row 1 columns 3–6, row 2 columns 4–6, row 3 columns 5–6 (9 cells) | — |
| Hallway | (2,3), row 3 columns 3–4, row 4 columns 1–5 (8 cells) | Table (4,4), carpet (4,5) |
| Basement | (4,6), row 5 columns 2–6 (6 cells) | Shelf (5,2) |
| Cellar | (5,1), row 6 columns 1–6 (7 cells) | Crate (6,6) |
The table, shelf and crate cells stayed empty for the whole game — nobody was placed on them and they never got a cross. That is our observation from the board; the tutorial lists objects such as crates as scenery that cannot be occupied.
Clue-by-clue reasoning
James — “He was on a chair.”
Only one chair exists on the board, in the Rooftop room.
→ James = (3,2), the chair cell. Row 3 and column 2 are now taken.
Daniel — “He was on a carpet.”
Only one carpet exists, in the Hallway next to the small table.
→ Daniel = (4,5), the carpet cell. Row 4 and column 5 are now taken.
Charlotte — “She was not in a corner of the room. She was in the top row.”
The Pool is the only room with a top-row stretch this long: row 1, columns 3–6. We read “corner of the room” as the room’s outer corners, (1,3) and (1,6), which leaves (1,4) and (1,5).
→ Column 5 is Daniel’s, so Charlotte = (1,4). Her clue narrowed it to two cells; the column rule picked one.
Katherine — “She was beside a shelf.”
“Beside” means directly above, below, left or right — never diagonal. The shelf is at (5,2), so the candidates are (4,2), (6,2), (5,1) and (5,3). Column 2 is James’s, which removes (4,2) and (6,2).
→ Katherine is (5,1) or (5,3). Row 5 either way, but the column is not settled yet.
Eleanor — “She was in the bottom row.”
Only one room touches the bottom row: the Cellar. Her row is 6. Column 2 (James), 4 (Charlotte) and 5 (Daniel) are taken, and (6,6) is the crate, so she can only be at (6,1) or (6,3).
→ Eleanor = (6,1) or (6,3). Katherine and Eleanor use columns 1 and 3 between them — see the swap below.
Marco — “The victim. He was alone with the killer.”
Marco’s clue gives no cell. The game does not pre-place him; you place him like everyone else. Once the other five hold rows 1, 3, 4, 5 and 6 and columns 1–5, only row 2 and column 6 are left.
→ Marco = (2,6), in the Pool. The only other suspect in the Pool is Charlotte, so she is the killer.
Where it is easy to go wrong
After the six clues, two layouts survive the row/column rule and both match “bottom row” and “beside a shelf” as the tutorial words them:
- A: Katherine (5,1), Eleanor (6,3) — both in the Cellar, Basement empty.
- B: Katherine (5,3), Eleanor (6,1) — Katherine in the Basement, Eleanor in the Cellar.
Our observation: we submitted A first and the game answered “Not quite right”; B was accepted. The shelf stands in the Basement, so the clue only works for Katherine if she is in the Basement too. That matches the room rule on How to play (Step 2), although the tutorial does not spell out this exact case. If a “beside” clue leaves you with two cells, check which room the object is in.
The solved board
One person per row, one per column — the full placement. Thick lines are room borders.
| ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | C | ✕ | ✕ |
| ✕Rooftop | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | ✕Pool | M |
| ✕ | J | ✕Hallway | ✕ | ✕ | ✕ |
| ✕ | ✕ | ✕ | table | D | ✕ |
| ✕ | shelf | K | ✕Basement | ✕ | ✕ |
| E | ✕ | ✕Cellar | ✕ | ✕ | crate |
C Charlotte (killer), M Marco (victim), J James, D Daniel, K Katherine, E Eleanor. Row 1 is the top row; column 1 is on the left.
🔍 The killer was Charlotte
She shared the Pool with Marco — the one condition the game always uses to name the culprit.
Want more worked examples?
Row and column uniqueness gets you most of the way, but checking the exact wording of a clue finishes the job — this case shows both, and it comes up constantly on harder boards.
More walkthroughs & deeper strategy
- Object Glossary – every tile explained
- Strategy Guide – advanced deduction patterns
- How to Play – the six core rules
